However, it felt detached from the horrors. I found the epilogue, where the author describes meeting with victims who cannot or will not speak more of the horrors they encountered, to be the most compelling p This book attempts to answer the question of why the Nazi regime declared war on gay men. I found the epilogue, where the author describes meeting with victims who cannot or will not speak more of the horrors they encountered, to be the most compelling part of this book—telling the story of those poor men, rather than the story of those who declared war on them.
Jun 15, Kerry rated it really liked it. It's always hard to rate books about horrible events, but I have to say this book felt timely and important. While the author didn't always have the statistics to back up his and his interviewee's impressions especially when comparing the situation of different groups within the camps , he provides the reader with the information he had gathered by , and that information was incredibly impactful.
Related to the publication date, the author does use terms that would be considered outdated no It's always hard to rate books about horrible events, but I have to say this book felt timely and important. Related to the publication date, the author does use terms that would be considered outdated nowadays. Starts out with the politics and agendas of those in power in Nazi Germany, then documents the struggles of victims of concentration camps and ends with searches for lost companions.
Heartbreaking search for lost companions during the rise of the Third Reich and the war. Explores the policies and politics leading to extermination of homosexual men in concentration camps. And, finally on the liberation of the death camps, additional imprisonment by Allied forces.
Mar 12, Jenine Young rated it really liked it Shelves: Nov 18, Julia Bruce rated it really liked it. Dec 12, Jennifer rated it it was amazing. It's appalling how little has been written about the fate of homosexuals under the Third Reich. This book, along with Heinz Heger's "The Men with the Pink Triangle" are the only two books I've ever seen that attempt to document and tell the stories that have been for so long overlooked. This is due in part to the lack of documents, but also due to the fact that so few survivors were willing or able to speak on their experiences.
After the liberation of the camps, homosexuals were still treated a It's appalling how little has been written about the fate of homosexuals under the Third Reich. After the liberation of the camps, homosexuals were still treated as criminals. Plant writes, "According to German law, homosexual ex-prisoners were to be treated as criminals.
How Nazi Pink Triangles Symbol Was Reclaimed for LGBT Pride | Time
East Germany voided the Nazi version of Paragraph only in ; West Germany followed in , adding minor alterations in Moreover, some American and British jurists of the liberation armies, on learning that an image had been jailed and then put into camp for homosexual activities, ruled that, judicially, a camp did not constitute a prison. If, therefore, someone had been sentenced to eight years in prison, had spent five of these in jail and three in a camp, he still had to finish three years in jail after liberation.
In at least one instance, a homosexual camp detainee was given a stern lecture by an American colonel, informing him that the United States also considered what he had done criminally offensive. For homosexuals, the Third Reich did not fully end with it's defeat. None of the lucky few who came out alive was granted any compensation when the new post-war West German government, bowing to American pressure, set up a cumbersome but functioning legal bureaucracy to grant restitution to political, Jewish and other selected ex-inmates.
Still, there must be more written and talked about on this. Only by learning about the past can we make sure it doesn't happen again. None of the horrors that the Third Reich unleashed on the world must ever happen again to any minority. Jun 24, MAP rated it liked it Shelves: This is one of the first books that catalogued the treatment of gay men by Nazi Germany.
The book breaks down the prevailing sentiment pre-Nazi, discusses Ernst Roehm and the night of the long knives, gives a biographical sketch of Himmler, and goes into the persecution and camp conditions of men sentenced under paragraph Unfortunately at this point there's not much in this book that you can't get off of Wikipedia, which I'm sure in turn got much of its material from this book.
But if you've already read up on this topic and were looking for something more in depth, this book doesn't really have much extra to offer. It also doesn't have much of any first hand accounts. Overall, in , it's worth it if you're new to the topic, but not so much if you're already somewhat well-versed. I'm sure people reading it when it first came out in the s would feel differently, and for that it deserves credit.
Nov 24, Sean Hastings rated it liked it. I was hoping this was gong to be a bit more detailed than it actually was. It did read as someone's doctoral thesis at times and a lot of the information was rehashed again and again. Plant does not really go in to detail of the actual treatment of the prisoners other to say that we know what happened and that there was no need to relive the gory details of the persecution of gay men in the concentration camps but I found this to be part of the reason why I wanted to read his book in the first p I was hoping this was gong to be a bit more detailed than it actually was.
Plant does not really go in to detail of the actual treatment of the prisoners other to say that we know what happened and that there was no need to relive the gory details of the persecution of gay men in the concentration camps but I found this to be part of the reason why I wanted to read his book in the first place. Not that I have a morbid fascination for the horror that happened, but the subject is not explored in the history books as that of the experience of the Jews, gypsies etc. I also found the back story of the hierarchy of some of the Nazi elite to be interesting only to be abruptly ended without a smooth transition.
In the end, it was worth the read and was generally easy to follow with the ending search for a long lost friend coming to the inevitable. Dec 11, Laura rated it liked it. This is an important, and unfortunately too little known, aspect of the Nazi regime - the incarceration and execution of gay men. While this book is a little longer, I felt that The Men with the Pink Triangle was actually more informative on what life was like for gay men under the Nazi regime. Thi This is an important, and unfortunately too little known, aspect of the Nazi regime - the incarceration and execution of gay men.
This book focused more on actions at the top - Hitler, Himmler, Roehm, and the like. Focusing on these political characters took away from the power of survivors stories. Jan 15, Cait rated it really liked it. An incredible and gripping account of the Holocaust that I never would have thought of or known about until I read this book.
It has such an incredible combination of emotion, personal account and voice, and history in it--I would highly recommend it to anyone, both in and out of the queer community, and I plan to lend it out to a bunch of my friends after I've told them about the book. I would be really interested to read about lesbianism during the Holocaust May 02, Diane Schneider rated it liked it.
A good attempt at a comprehensive look at the treatment of homosexuals in Nazi Germany. The inclusion of the author's personal story of the persecution of homosexuals is especially poignant.
Unfortunately, as the author notes, the book suffers from the fact that evidence is hard to come by. Despite that, the book is still an important read, especially with regard to our country's current political attitude toward homosexuality. As the author says, "The specters begin to come to life whenever fan A good attempt at a comprehensive look at the treatment of homosexuals in Nazi Germany.
As the author says, "The specters begin to come to life whenever fanatical fundamentalists of any sect -- religious or secular -- take over a nation and call for a holy war against its most vulnerable and vilified minorities. Jan 06, Daniel rated it really liked it. We all are aware of the horrors perpetrated by Hitler and his cronies so to say I was surprised by anything I read in this book wouldn't be true. However I was a little caught off guard to learn that after the camps were liberated the gay population were transferred to other prisons to complete their sentences.
They were the only segment of the camp population that did not receive any reparations by the new German government. It makes you wonder what is wrong with people and why is there so much We all are aware of the horrors perpetrated by Hitler and his cronies so to say I was surprised by anything I read in this book wouldn't be true.
It makes you wonder what is wrong with people and why is there so much hatred directed at the gay population. I guess society always needs a scapegoat and religion gives people the OK to continually treat gays as second or even third hand citizens Jan 18, Mary rated it liked it Shelves: An interesting book on one of the lesser known targets of the Third Reich. While the book is a fantastic resource especially since it was one of the first books to really address the subject, I would have preferred to read something with a bit of a human side to it as well.
Jan 18, Alan rated it it was amazing.
- How the Nazi Regime's Pink Triangle Symbol Was Repurposed for LGBTQ Pride.
- Looking Up: A Humorous and Unflinching Account of Learning to Live Again With Sudden Disability.
- Legacies: Part Two of The SCION Trilogy.
- The Book Hunter in Paris;
- Winter King: The Dawn of Tudor England?
- Girl, Youll Be A Woman Soon.
The only book on this subject. Richard Plant writes from the perspective of a gay German whose grandfather was a Rabbi. Richard left Germany for America in Aug 28, wrench rated it really liked it Shelves: This is a very short, concise history of homosexual persecution by nazis. Something I really appreciate about this is the fact that Plant feels no need to go into massive depth about the horrific details, citing that most histories have well covered them.
He is simply filling in a piece of a larger history, and I think that this book does a very good job of that. Aug 16, Luke Brennan rated it really liked it Shelves: A bit light on detail and doesn't always let the facts speak for themselves. The facts alone are more than enough without unnecessary and unwelcome personal opinions from theauthor. Otherwise, situates the subject very well in context and shows how what motivated the nazis here was actually wanting to build a perverse utopia based on ever so slightly erroneous beliefs. Apr 21, Abbyg.
The most moving parts of this book are the prologue and epilogue. The scholarship is sandwiched in between heart-rending personal reflections on the author's life before the war and, upon his return visit to Germany to conduct research for this book. Dec 06, Aaron S rated it it was amazing. This book chronicles a neglected piece of World War II history and it is handled sensitively in a well-written manner. With rich historical insight and personal reflection and commentary by Richard Plant; The Pink Triangle is incredibly heartbreaking and harrowing and it demands your attention.
Jul 04, Natina El rated it it was ok. A little rushed , but I'm glad it wasn't as vulgar as other camp stories. I learned a few things Maybe a few differences but foundations stay the same. Apr 19, Rose rated it liked it. It's basically a history book you'd read in school, not a first hand account from a survivor. It deals more with dates and people than experiences and personal reflection. May 17, Rachel rated it liked it. This book is very factual on the gay and lesbians during the holocaust. It is very interesting to read if you are unfamiliar with what they went through.
There are no discussion topics on this book yet. Until there was an unofficial ban on placing pink triangle wreaths at the United Kingdom war memorial the Cenotaph , and such wreaths were removed as soon as they were found by officials. Pink triangle Rosa Winkel in German memorial for gay men killed at Buchenwald. In the Berlin Nollendorfplatz subway station , a pink triangle plaque honors gay male victims. Amsterdam's Homomonument uses pink triangles symbolically to memorialize gay men killed in the Holocaust and also victims of anti-gay violence generally.
Sydney Gay and Lesbian Holocaust Memorial. From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia. For the Weezer song, see Pink Triangle song. For the British audio manufacturer, see Pink Triangle audio manufacturer. The Nazi War against Homosexuals revised ed. Transgenders and Nazi Germany". Retrieved August 22, United States Holocaust Memorial Museum. Retrieved 24 August Male Homosexuality in West Germany: Between Persecution and Freedom, Interdisciplinary Approaches to Genders and Sexualities. Retrieved 22 August Journal of the History of Sexuality.
Archived from the original on In the early s, gay rights organizations in Germany and the United States launched campaigns to reclaim the pink triangle. In the German gay liberation group Homosexuelle Aktion Westberlin HAW called upon gay men to wear the pink triangle as a memorial. American Journal of Public Health.
The Pink Triangle: The Nazi War Against Homosexuals
Recognizing the history of the pink triangle". Retrieved 27 April Changing Corporate America from Inside Out: Lesbian and Gay Workplace Rights. Retrieved 1 June Lush Fresh Handmade Cosmetics. Lesbian , gay , bisexual , and transgender LGBT topics. Gender identities Sexual identities Sexual diversities. Asexual Bisexual Heterosexual Homosexual. Gender and Sexual Diversity Erotic target location error Gender roles Human female sexuality Human male sexuality Sexuality and gender identity-based cultures Intersex Hermaphrodite.
Related The Pink Triangle: The Nazi War Against Homosexuals
Copyright 2019 - All Right Reserved