While The Paper Bag Princess is still my favorite of his books, this one is very close. Jul 04, Carolyn James rated it liked it Shelves: In the book, a young girl breaks her promise, is pulled into icy water by monsters and has to promise to give her siblings up to get free. The moral of the story is to keep your promises since the whole story starts by her breaking one to her mother but it may be a little scary for young kids, so think about the age group you plan to share this with.
Feb 22, Jennifer rated it it was amazing. A suspenseful book that teaches children to listen to their parents and to follow through on promises. A little girl goes fishing in the sea ice, when a monster takes her captive. He agrees to let her go only if she promises to bring her brother and sister to him so he can eat them. The mother finds out and very creatively saves the day.
This book uses vivid language, and may frighten children. Nov 18, Sheri rated it liked it. Old story from Inuit Indians about the monsters in the ice cracks who will steal children if they dare come out and fish near the oceans. Book dates back from , story about oldest daughter disobeying parents and going fishing in the ice cracks and then promising Qalllupilluit to bring them her brothers and sisters in exchange for her escape.
- A Promise is a Promise by Robert Munsch!
- The State Courts!
- See a Problem?.
- Fallen Forests: Emotion, Embodiment, and Ethics in American Womens Environmental Writing, 1781-1924.
- How do you say that??
- Navigation menu?
- Study Nos. 1-20.
The importance of the promise and how they trick these imaginary creatures into not harming the children. One day she disobeys her mothers warnings and decides to go fishing on the sea ice.
A Promise is a Promise
Under the sea ice lives Quallupilluit who take children who are alone and not guarded by their parents. Traditional Indigenous storytelling is a favourite of mine and this book definitely lives up to the standards. The sort is full of suspense and will engage children. Apr 19, Kimberly rated it it was amazing Shelves: This is one of my favorite Munsch books. Firstly, it is a great tale with a great message for kids. Secondly, the story is delivered without an overkill of onomatopoeia.
This is a fun book to read, full of suspense and enough "spooky" lines to entrance the reader. Good for multiethnic classes, such as social studies, when looking at beliefs and tradition. A book that would be enjoyed by all ages. Feb 21, Kristin rated it it was amazing. The troll-like Qallupilluq drag her under the ice and Allashua and her family must trick the Qallupilluq in order to survive. The gentle horizontal lines of the horizon are softened by color in the sky and the land on the horizon line, the sky mirroring the underlying land and vice versa. Feb 14, Rose Ann rated it it was ok Shelves: It was kind of creepy, and my son was a little scared by it.
As an adult, I understand the lesson, about not going near the cracked ice. But this was a bit of a scary tactic that seems extreme. Mar 07, Paula rated it liked it Shelves: Received a copy from NetGalley. It was different than his usual picture books and not as upbeat and funny. The illustrations, as usual, were well done and added to the story. The story is unique and I like the fact that it ties to a cultural few books have been printed about. It is pretty lengthy for young children and is geared towards older children such as Kindergarten and older.
Feb 07, Michelle Wyatt rated it it was amazing Shelves: This book is sort of dark, but it teaches kids a good lesson. The little girl didn't listen to her mom, and she had to pay a consequence when she went to the ice. The lesson to be learned is that there are consequences for your actions, but any number of others can be pulled from this book. Jan 20, Joanna Coleman rated it it was ok. We love all of Munsch's books, but this one is a little creepy.
It kind of scared my kids. I recommend all his books for great read aloud fun, just be aware this one is about a creepy ocean creature that wants to kidnap a child. Oct 24, Susan rated it it was ok Shelves: Obviously a tale designed to keep children safe.
- Almost All Aliens: Immigration, Race, and Colonialism in American History and Identity.
- Essential Words for the GRE.
- A Time to Change;
- a promise is a promise?
- Kann denn Essen Sünde sein?: Wer richtig genießt, bleibt gesund und schlank (German Edition).
- Study Nos. 1-20!
- A Promise is a Promise — Michael Kusugak.
However, I think it is also one that would certainly have given me nightmares as a child and I lived nowhere near an ocean. Heck, I think it will likely give me nightmares now Feb 20, Kate rated it did not like it Shelves: This book is terrifying. I would not read it to a child unless my only goal was to prevent them from playing on the ice I will not be using this for Storytime for any age group.
Sep 18, Monica rated it it was amazing Shelves: This folk tale takes place in the arctic and it warns of potential dangers in this climate. Folk tales are great for all ages because it is good lesson for children and it also gives a window into other cultures. I would mainly use it to show the cultural diversity aspect. Mar 23, Jamie E rated it liked it Shelves: Good cautionary tale for children. At first I was a bit taken aback by the scariness of the story, forgetting that children's books tend to seem darker to adults than they do kids.
Jan 24, Rivkah rated it it was amazing. Defiantly my favorite Robert Munsch book. A good moral tale. It has a really good message and its super clever but I thought it was a bit on the dark side. Jul 19, Ashley-Anne rated it liked it Shelves: This was actually pretty creepy but now as an adult I rather like the story. Nov 08, Liz Todd rated it it was ok Shelves: Parents even comment that the girl makes "dumb" choices. Sep 27, Kimberly rated it it was amazing. I haven't read this book in about 15 years but it was a favourite while growing up.
The story is amazing the author is amazing and this is one that I will definately be reading to my babies. Jun 24, Andrea rated it it was amazing Shelves: I remember this book was kinda of sad but awww at the same time because of the family. The drawings are breathtaking, so beautiful. Dec 07, Engel Dreizehn rated it it was amazing.
Still as fun and beautiful as I remembered it. Mar 09, Katie Bergansen rated it it was ok Shelves: I understand the purpose of the story is safety and I respect the heritage of the story. It was poorly written, though. With Munsch's name on it, I expected more. It had no flow.
Sep 08, Nojood Alsudairi rated it really liked it Shelves: There are no discussion topics on this book yet. Robert Munsch was born in Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania.
a promise is a promise - Wiktionary
He graduated from Fordham University in with a Bachelor of Arts degree in history and from Boston University in with a Master of Arts degree in anthropology. He studied to become a Jesuit priest, but decided he would rather work with children after jobs at orphanages and daycare centers.
He also taught in the Department of Family Studies at the University of Guelph as a lecturer and as an assistant professor. In Guelph he was encouraged to publish the many stories he made up for the children he worked with. Munsch's wife delivered two stillborn babies in and Out of the tragedy, he produced one of his best-known books, Love You Forever. This book was listed fourth on the Publishers Weekly All-Time Best selling Children's Books list for paperbacks at 6,, copies not including the 1,, hardcover copies.
We sent it back and forth and back and forth and back and forth and back and forth and finally it turned into this story called A Promise Is A Promise.
The Official Website of Robert Munsch
The pictures in the story are very strange. The lady who did the pictures is named Vladyana Krykorka.
She is in Toronto, she has never been to the Northwest Territories. The father is named Medard. He is from Chesterfield Inlet. She took people from different families and glued them together into one family. A Promise is a Promise. Written by Robert Munsch.
Related A Promise is A Promise
Copyright 2019 - All Right Reserved